¤j¨§²Ë¹L¼ö³B²z·|­°§C

¥Íª«¥i§Q¥ÎÓi°ò»Ä¤§§t¶q

        ¹ï©Ò¦³®a¸V¦Ó¨¥¡A¤j¨§²Ë¬°Ói°ò»Äªº­«­n¨Ó·½¡A¦ý¥¼¸g³B²z¤§¤j¨§²Ë§t¦³¤@¨Ç§ÜÀç¾i¦]¤l¡A¥]§t§¿¯Àú@©M¯Ø³J¥Õú@§í¨î¦]¤l¡A³Ì­«­nªº¬O³o¨Ç§ÜÀç¾i¦]¤l¦b¤ô¤À¦s¦b®É¡A¥iÂǥѥ[¼ö³B²z¦Ó³Q¯}Ãa¡C¥[¼ö©Î¯MµH³B²z¬°§ïµ½®a¸V¹ï¤j¨§²ËÀç¾i»ù­Èªº­«­n¹Lµ{¡AµM¦Ó¥[¼ö³B²z¥ç·|¯}ÃaÀç¾i¤À¡A©Î¦]¤£¥i®ø¤Æ½Æ¦Xª«ªº§Î¦¨¦Ó¼vÅTÀç¾i¤À¤§®ø¤Æ²v¡C¦]¦¹¡F¥[¼ö¹Lµ{¤¤¡A¯}Ãa§ÜÀç¾i¦]¤l»P¹L¼öµ{«×¤§¶¡ºû«ùºë½Tªº¥­¿Å¬Û·í­«­n¡C

        Parsonsµ¥¤H(1992)°µ¤F¤@¨t¦C¸ÕÅç¨Óµû¦ô¹L¼ö³B²z¹ï¤j¨§²Ë¤§Ói°ò»Ä»P¯à¶q§t¶q¤§®ø¤Æ²vªº¼vÅT¡C¨ú¦Û¥ì§Q¿Õ·í¦a¨â­Ó°Ó·~©Ê¥Í²£¹}®Æ¤u¼t¤§¥h´ß·»¾¯µÑ¨ú¤j¨§²Ë¡A¸g¥[¼ö³B²z¹F¨ì°Ó·~¼Ð·Ç¡CParson«ü¥X¡A³o¨Ç¼Ë«~¨ä§¿¯Àú@­È¬ù¬°0.20³æ¦ìªºpH¡A±N³o¨Ç¤j¨§²Ë¥H¹êÅç¥Î»]¨TÁçÄl¦bÀ£¤O¬°105KPA(Kilo Pascal¡A6.895 KPA¡×1½S¡þ¥­¤è­^¦T)(15³Ä¡þ¥­¤è­^¦T)¡A·Å«×¬°121¢J¤U¥[¼ö¡A®É¶¡¤À§O¬°20¡B40¤Î60¤ÀÄÁ¡Cªí1©ÒÅã¥Ü¬°±Ä¥ÎÂ÷¤l¥æ´«¦â¼h¤ÀªRªk¡A©Ò´ú©w¤§¤j¨§²Ë¤¤Ói°ò»Ä¿@«×¤ÀªR­È¡A¨ä¤¤¥Ò²¸Ói»Ä»P¯ÖÓi»Ä¬O¥H¹L¥Ò»Ä®ñ¤Æ³B²z¤ÀÂ÷«á¦A¤ÀªR¡C¤j¨§²Ë¤¤¤§Â÷Ói»Ä¡B¯ÖÓi»Ä»PºëÓi»Ä¡AÀHµÛ¥[¼ö®É¶¡¼Wªø¦Ó´î¤Ö¡A¥[¼ö³B²z¹ïÂ÷Ói»Ä¿@«×¼vÅT³Ì¤j¡A¥[¼ö40¤Î60¤ÀÄÁ¡AÂ÷Ói»Ä¿@«×¤À§O­°§C15¢H»P22¢H¡A¥[¼ö40»P60¤ÀÄÁ«á¡A¨ä¥¦Ói°ò»ÄÁöµM¤]´î¤Ö¡A¦ý´î¤Öµ{«×¸ûÂ÷Ói»Ä¤Ö¡A¥[¼ö¹ï²Ê³J¥Õ½è§t¶q«hµL¼vÅT¡C

ªí1. ¥[¼ö®É¶¡¹ï¥h´ß¤j¨§²ËÓi°ò»Ä²Õ¦¨ªº¼vÅT1'2

Ói°ò»Ä ¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë¼Ë«~1 ¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë¼Ë«~2
03 20 40 0 20 40 60
¤Ñªù¥VÓi»Ä 5.54 5.59 5.46 5.53 5.57 5.27 5.23
ßm¤BÓi»Ä 1.89 1.92 1.87 1.88 1.99 1.79 1.78
µ·Ói»Ä 2.33 2.37 2.28 2.42 2.44 2.30 2.27
¾¢Ói»Ä 8.87 8.86 8.80 8.77 8.87 8.41 8.35
²ãÓi»Ä 2.47 2.46 2.47 2.44 2.47 2.35 2.32
¥ÌÓi»Ä 1.96 1.99 1.91 2.04 2.06 1.95 1.95
¤þÓi»Ä 2.05 2.11 2.03 2.12 2.14 2.03 2.03
¯ÖÓi»Ä 0.70 0.66 0.63 0.73 0.72 0.67 0.64
õéÓi»Ä 2.28 2.37 2.31 2.31 2.33 2.24 2.23
¥Ò²¸Ói»Ä 0.71 0.71 0.70 0.68 0.70 0.67 0.70
²§¥ÕÓi»Ä 2.15 2.16 2.15 2.26 2.28 2.19 2.17
¥ÕÓi»Ä 3.84 3.90 3.75 3.76 3.82 3.63 3.60
¹TÓi»Ä 1.50 1.50 1.49 1.52 1.55 1.34 1.45
­f¤þÓi»Ä 2.39 2.42 2.38 2.45 2.47 2.35 2.33
²ÕÓi»Ä 1.25 1.24 1.20 1.28 1.28 1.20 1.18
Â÷Ói»Ä 3.27 2.95 2.76 3.15 2.95 2.65 2.47
ºëÓi»Ä 3.44 3.43 3.21 3.50 3.52 3.21 3.15

        ¬Y´XºØÓi°ò»Ä§t¶qªº´î¤Ö¡A¯S§O¬OÂ÷Ói»Ä§t¶qªº´î¤Ö¡A¥i¯à¬O¥Ñ©óÓi°ò»Ä©M¦hÁÞÃþ¤§¶¡½Å¤Æ¤ÏÀ³²£¥Í±ö¯Ç²£ª«(Maillard products)¡A¦Ó¤j¨§²Ë¤¤§tÂ×´Iªº¹è¦hÁÞÃþ¦pµæ¨§¿}©M´Óª«»e¿}¡A¥i¯à°Ñ»P½Å¤Æ¤ÏÀ³¡C

        ¦ý¸g°ª«×¥[¼ö³B²z«á¡A¬°¦ó·|¾É­P§t²¸Ói°ò»Ä§t¶q´î¤Ö¡A¤´¤£²M·¡¡A¦Ó¤Ö¶q¯ÖÓi»Ä·|ÂàÅܦ¨¦Ï¤ò²¸Ói»Ä(lanthionine)¡A¦Ï¤ò²¸Ói»Ä¬°¹L«×¥[¼ö®É§t²¸Ói°ò»Äªº¥æ®t³sµ²©Ò§Î¦¨¡C³oµ²ªG²M·¡¦aÅã¥Ü¥X¡A¹L«×¥[¼ö·|­°§C¤j¨§²Ë¤¤Â÷Ói»Ä©M¨ä¥L´XºØÓi°ò»Äªº¤ÀªR­È¡C¥H¤G­Ó¸ÕÅç¨Óµû¦ô¥[¼ö¤j¨§²Ë¹ïÂû°¦¥Íªø©Êª¬©MÓi°ò»Ä»P¯à¶q¤§¯u®ø¤Æ²vªº¼vÅT¡A©Ò¦³ªº¸ÕÅç³£±Ä¥Îªí1¤¤¼Ë«~1¤§¤j¨§²Ë¡A¸ÕÅç1¥H¥¼¥[¼ö©Î¥[¼ö40¤À¤§¤j¨§²Ë§@¬°¹}³¥D­n³J¥Õ½è¨Ó·½¡A§t²Ê³J¥Õ½è23¢H¤§¤j¨§²Ë¢w¸²µå¿}¹}³Áý¹}1¶gÄ֦פ½Âû¡Aµ²ªGÅã¥Ü©óªí2¡A¤j¨§²Ë¥[¼ö40¤À¡AÅé¼W­«»P¹}®Æ®Ä²v¤À§O­°§C¤F28¢H»P18¢H¡A¥B¹F²Î­p¤WÅãµÛ®t²§(P¡Õ0.001)¡C¥t±Ä¥Î³Î°£ª¼¸z©Î¥¼³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦¡A¥Hºë½Tµ¹¹}ªk¨Ó´ú©w¥[¼ö©Î¥¼¥[¼ö¤j¨§²Ëªº´áÁB¥¿¯u¥NÁ¯à»PÓi°ò»Ä¤§¯u®ø¤Æ²v¡Aªí3©ÒÅã¥Ü¬°Â÷Ói»Ä¤§¯u®ø¤Æ²v¡AµL½×¥[¼ö®É¶¡ªøµu¡A³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦¨äÓi°ò»Ä¤§¯u®ø¤Æ²v¸û¥¼³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦¬°§C¡A³\¦h¸ÕÅç¤w«ü¥X¡A¦¹¥i¯à«Y¥Ñ©ó¥¼³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦ª¼¸z¤º²ÓµßÃæ»Ã§@¥Îªº¼vÅT¡C¥[¼ö­°§C¤j¨§²Ë¤¤Â÷Ói»Ä¤§¯u®ø¤Æ²v¡A³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦¹ï¥¼¥[¼ö¤j¨§²ËÂ÷Ói»Ä¤§¯u®ø¤Æ²v¬°90.8¢H¡A¥[¼ö40¤À«á¡AÂ÷Ói»Ä¯u®ø¤Æ²v­°¦Ü69.2¢H¡A¦pªG¥H¥[¼ö40¤À«á¤§¤j¨§²Ë¤¤Â÷Ói»Ä§t¶q¬°­pºâ°ò·Ç¡A«hÂ÷Ói»Ä¯u®ø¤Æ²v¬°81.8¢H¡A¹F¨ì²Î­p¤W¤§ÅãµÛ®t²§(P¡Õ0.001)¡A³o¨Çµ²ªGÅã¥Ü¡A¥[¼ö¤£¶È­°§C¥HÂ÷¤l¦â¼h¤ÀªRªk©Ò´ú©w¤§¼Ë«~¤¤Â÷Ói»Ä§t¶q¡A¥ç­°§C¼Ë«~¤¤³Ñ¾lÂ÷Ói»Äªº¯u®ø¤Æ²v¡C²Ä¤T­Ó¸ÕÅç¬O¥HÂû°¦¥Íªø¸ÕÅç¨Óµû¦ô¤j¨§²Ë¤¤Â÷Ói»Ä¤§¥Íª«¥i§Q¥Î²v¡A¥H¥É¦Ì¢w¥É¦Ì¾¢½è¬°¥D¡A¯Ê¥FÂ÷Ói»Ä¤§°ò¦¹}³¤¤²K¥[¦UºØ§t¶q¤§L¢wÂ÷Ói»Ä¡A°ò¦¹}³¥ç²K¥[3¢H©Î6¢H¸g¥[¼ö40¤À©Î¥¼¥[¼ö¤§¤j¨§²Ë¡Aµ²´¹«¬L¢wÂ÷Ói»Ä¤§¥Íª«¥i§Q¥Î²v°²³]¬°100¢H¡A¥[¼ö¤j¨§²Ë»P¥¼¥[¼ö¤j¨§²Ë¤¤¤§Â÷Ói»Ä§t¶q°²³]¬Û¦P¡A¥HÂ÷Ói»Ä¤§Äá­¹¶q¹ïÅé¼W­«©Ò§@¤§¦h°jÂk¥Î±×²v¤ÀªR­pºâ¨D±o¤j¨§²ËÂ÷Ói»Ä¥Íª«¥i§Q¥Î²v¡A¸ÕÅç3ªºµ²ªG¦C¥Ü©óªí4¡A¥¼¥[¼ö¤j¨§²Ë¤§Â÷Ói»Ä¥Íª«¥i§Q¥Î²v¬°82¢H¡A¦Ó¬Û¦P¼Ë«~µ¹¹}³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦¡A¨ä¯u®ø¤Æ²v¬°90.8¢H¡A¤j¨§²Ë¤¤Â÷Ói»Ä¥Íª«¥i§Q¥Î²v¸û§Cªº­ì¦]¥Ø«e¤´¤£²M·¡¡CParsonsµ¥¤H«ü¥X¡A¦h½g¬ã¨s³ø§iÅã¥Ü¡A¥HÂû°¦¥Íªø¸ÕÅç©Ò´ú©w¤§¤j¨§²ËÂ÷Ói»Ä¥Íª«¥i§Q¥Î²v¬ù¬°80¢H¡A¥t¤@¨Ç¬ã¨s³ø§i«üºÙ¡A¤j¨§²ËªºÓi°ò»Ä¼Ò¦¡¥Î©óÂûªº¥Íªø¸ÕÅç¡A·|­°§CÂ÷Ói»Äªº§Q¥Î®Ä²v¥B§C¦ô¤FÂ÷Ói»Ä¤§¥Íª«¥i§Q¥Î²v¡C¥[¼ö40¤À«á¤§¤j¨§²Ë¥Íª«¥i§Q¥Î²v¬ù¬°70¢H¡A«D±`±µªñ¥H³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦©Ò´ú±oªº¯u®ø¤Æ²v(69.2¢H)¡Aªí5Åã¥Ü¸ÕÅç¤G©Ò´ú©w°£¤FÂ÷Ói»Ä¥H¥~¤§¨ä¥¦Ói°ò»Ä¯u®ø¤Æ²v¡A¼vÅT³Ì¤j¬°¯ÖÓi»Ä¡B²ÕÓi»Ä»P¤Ñªù¥VÓi»Ä¡Cªí6Åã¥Ü¤j¨§²Ë¤§´áÁB¥¿¯u¥NÁ¯à§t¶q¡A¥¼³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦¨ä´áÁB¥¿¯u¥NÁ¯à¸û³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦¬°°ª¡A¥¼³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦¨ä¯à¶q¦³³¡¤À¥i¯à¨Ó¦Ûª¼¸z¤º·L¥Íª«©Ò²£¥Íªº¯×ªÕ»Ä¡AÁöµM¥[¼ö©úÅã¦a­°§C¤j¨§²Ë¤¤¤@¨ÇÓi°ò»Äªº®ø¤Æ²v¡A¦ý¹ï´áÁB¥¿¯u¥NÁ¯à­È«hµL¼vÅT¡C¾Ú±À´ú¥[¼ö¾É­P¤j¨§²Ë¤¤Ói°ò»Ä®ø¤Æ²vªº­°§C¡A¥i¯à¬O¦]¤j¨§²Ë¥[¼ö®É¡AÓi°ò»Ä¤@ºÒ¤ô¤Æ¦Xª«½Æ¦Xª«©M¨ä¥¦Ói°ò»Ä½Æ¦Xª«ªº§Î¦¨©Ò­P¡A¦ý¨Ã¥¼­°§C¤j¨§²Ë¤§¯à¶q­È¡A¤j³¡¤ÀÓi°ò»Ä½Æ¦Xª«¬O»P¹èÁÞÃþµ²¦X©Ò²£¥Í¡A§Y¨Ï¤£»PÓi°ò»Ä§Î¦¨½Æ¦Xª«¡A®a¸V¹ï¹èÁÞÃþ¤§§Q¥Î«Ü®t¡C¥Ñ¤W­±¤§¸ÕÅç±oª¾¡AÁý¹}¹L¼ö¤j¨§²Ë¾É­PÂû°¦¥Íªø©Êª¬¤£¨}ªº­ì¦]¡A¥D­n¬OÓi°ò»Ä¥Íª«¥i§Q¥Î²v­°§C¤§¬G¡CÀç¾i±M®a¦p¦ó¯à§P§O¹L¼ö¤j¨§²Ë¬O§_¤w¾D¯}Ãa¡H¥H¦â¼h¤ÀªR¤èªk¤ÀªRÂ÷Ói»Ä¬O­Ó«Ü¦nªº«ü¼Ð¡A¦ý¦â¼h¤ÀªRªk©ù¶Q¥B¶O®É¡A§¿¯Àú@­È(pH¼W¥[³æ¦ì)¤w´¶¹M³Q¥Î¨Ó´ú©w¤j¨§²Ë³B²z©Î¥[¼öªºµ{«×¡AParsons«ü¥X¡A¤j³¡¤À°Ó·~¥Í²£ªº¤j¨§²Ë¨äpH¤§¼W¥[­È¤¶©ó0.20~0.00¤§¶¡¡AParsons¸ûÃÙ¦P§¿¯Àú@­È¤£§C©ó0.05¡A¦ý§¿¯Àú@­È§C¦Ü0.00®É¡A¨Ã¨S¦³©úÅã­°§C®a¸V¥Íªø©Êª¬¡C´ú©w³J¥Õ½è©ó²B®ñ¤Æ¹[¤¤¤§·»¸Ñ«×¬°´ú©w¤j¨§²Ë«~½è§ó¦nªº¤@ºØ¤èªk¡AParsonsµoªí¦b1991¦~ªº°Êª«´Á¥Z(Animal Science¡A1991)±Mªù³ø¾É³o­Ó¤èªk¸Ô²Óªº¾Þ§@¨BÆJ¡C

ªí2. Áý¹}¥[¼ö¤j¨§²Ë¹ïÂû°¦¥Íªø©Êª¬¤§¼vÅT(¸ÕÅç1)1

¹}³³B²z Åé¼W­« ¼W­«¡G¹}®Æ¤ñ
¸²µå¿}»P¥¼¥[¼ö¤j¨§²Ë¹}³ 102 700
¸²µå¿}»P¥[¼ö40¤À¤j¨§²Ë¹}³ 73 576
¦@¦P¼Ð·Ç°¾®t 1.5 11

1. 6~13¤éÄÖÂû°¦¡A¤»­«½Æ¡A¨C­«½Æ¤­°¦ªº¥­§¡­È¡A¸ÕÅç¶}©l¥­§¡Åé­«68§J¡C

2. ¹}³§t¦³48¢H¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë¡A44¢H¸²µå¿}¡A4¢H¥É¦Ìªo¡A2.2¢HÁC»Ä¤G¶t¡A1¢H¥Û¦Ç¥Û¯»¡A0.4¢H´â¤Æ¶u¡A0.2¢HDL¢w¥Ò²¸Ói»Ä¡A²K¥[·L¶qÄqª«½è©Mºû¥Í¯À¹F¨ìNRC(1984)»Ý­n¶q¡C

ªí3. ¥[¼ö»P³Î°£ª¼¸z¹ï¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë¤¤Â÷Ói»Ä¡B¯u®ø¤Æ²vªº¼vÅT(¸ÕÅç2)1

¥[¼ö®É¶¡(¤À) ¥H¥¼¥[¼ö¥h´ß¤j¨§²ËÂ÷Ói»Ä§t¶q©Ò´ú©w¤§®ø¤Æ²v ¥H¥[¼ö«á³Ñ¾l¤§Â÷Ói»Ä§t¶q©Ò´ú©w¤§®ø¤Æ²v
³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦ ¥¼³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦ ³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦ ¥¼³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦
0 90.8 93.8 90.8 93.8
20 77.9 79.7 86.2 88.2
40 69.2 72.4 81.8 85.6
¦@¦P¼Ð·Ç°¾®t 0.8 0.9

1. ®ø¤Æ²v¦Ê¤À¤ñ¡F¤T°¦Âû°¦¥­§¡­È¡C

2. ¥[¼ö®É¶¡»PÂû°¦«¬ºA¤§©úÅã¥D®ÄÀ³(P¡Õ0.001)¡A¥[¼ö®É¶¡¡ÑÂû°¦«¬ºA¨S¦³ÅãµÛ¥æ·P§@¥Î¡C

ªí4. ¸ÕÅç3¥HÂû°¦¥Íªø¸ÕÅç´ú©w¥[¼ö¹ï¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë¤¤Â÷Ói»Ä¥Íª«¥i§Q¥Î²v¤§¼vÅT1,2

³B²z ²K¥[Â÷Ói»ÄÄá­¹¶q(²@§J) Åé¼W­«(§J) ¼W­«¡G¹}®Æ

(§J¡G¤½¤ç)

¥Íª«¥i§Q¥Î²v

(¢H)3

1. °ò¦¹}³(B)4 0 44 327 ¡@
2. B+0.10¢HL- 167 67 403 100
3. B+0.20¢HL- 396 85 431 ¡@
4. B+3¢H¥¼¥[¼ö¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë 150 60 392 82±9
5. B+3¢H¥¼¥[¼ö¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë 326 73 440 ¡@
6. B+3¢H¥[¼ö40¤À¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë 142 54 373 ¡@
7. B+6¢H¥[¼ö40¤À¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë 332 71 420 70±8
¦@¦P¼Ð·Ç¾÷®t ¡@ 3 10 ¡@

1. ¨C³B²z¤T­«½Æ¡A¨C­«½Æ5°¦8~17¤Ñªº¥­§¡­È¡A¶}©l¥­§¡Åé­«76§J¡C

2. ¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë¥[¼ö0¤À¡A¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë¥[¼ö40¤À¡C

3. ²K¥[µ²´¹«¬Â÷Ói»Ä©Î¤j¨§²ËÂû°¦¤§Åé¼W­«(Y¡F§J)¹ïÂ÷Ói»ÄÄá­¹¶q(X¡F²@§J)¥H±×²v¤ÀªR¤§¦h¦¸°jÂk­pºâ¡C°jÂk¤èµ{¦¡Y¡×45.5¡Ï0.1055(Â÷Ói»Ä)¡Ï0.0865(¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë¥[¼ö0¤À)¡Ï0.0736(¥h´ß¤j¨§´ß¥[¼ö40¤À)¡AR2¡×0.91¡C

4. ¥É¦Ì©M¥É¦Ì¾¢½è¤Î¤j¨§²Ë¹}³§t0.55¢HÂ÷Ói»Ä¡C

ªí5. ¥[¼ö»P³Î°£ª¼¸z¹ï¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë¤¤Ói°ò»Ä®ø¤Æ²vªº¼vÅT(¸ÕÅç2)1

Ói°ò»Ä ³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦ ³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦ ¦@¦P¼Ð·Ç°¾®t ¥[¼ö®É¶¡ Âû°¦«¬ºA
02 20 40 0 20 40
¤Ñªù¥VÓi»Ä 88.6 81.1 72.4 94.0 90.4 85.9 0.8 * *
ßm¤BÓi»Ä 84.3 85.7 80.1 92.5 92.5 88.8 1.2 * *
µ·Ói»Ä 87.6 89.2 83.0 94.5 93.7 90.8 1.3 * *
¾¢Ói»Ä 93.0 91.0 86.2 96.1 94.4 91.9 0.6 * *
²ãÓi»Ä 90.8 90.7 86.7 95.7 94.7 94.4 1.1 NS *
¤þÓi»Ä 84.7 88.3 83.8 90.5 90.0 85.5 1.2 * *
¯ÖÓi»Ä 81.6 69.1 61.5 91.6 79.6 76.2 1.9 * *
õéÓi»Ä 87.4 92.7 89.0 93.1 95.1 93.1 1.2 NS *
¥Ò²¸Ói»Ä 85.6 86.3 83.3 86.5 86.3 83.9 1.8 NS NS
²§¥ÕÓi»Ä 90.5 91.6 91.2 95.2 94.2 93.6 1.0 NS *
¥ÕÓi»Ä 90.1 92.4 89.3 95.8 95.1 91.2 1.0 * *
¹TÓi»Ä 89.8 91.8 89.9 95.2 93.7 94.0 1.1 NS *
­f¤þÓi»Ä 92.8 95.5 92.7 95.5 95.9 94.0 0.9 NS NS
²ÕÓi»Ä 88.1 80.3 73.3 93.0 74.2 75.9 2.3 * NS
ºëÓi»Ä 92.9 91.9 85.8 95.9 92.3 87.0 1.1 * NS

1. ¥¼¥[¼ö¤j¨§²Ë¤¤Ói°ò»Ä§t¶q©Ò´ú©w3°¦Âûªº®ø¤Æ²v¤§¥­§¡­È¡C

2. ¥[¼ö®É¶¡¥H¤À­p

    *¥D®ÄÀ³¹F²Î­p¤WÅãµÛ®t²§(P¡Õ0.05)¡C

    NS¡×¥D®ÄÀ³»P¥[¼ö®É¶¡©MÂû°¦«¬ºA¥¼¹F²Î­p¤WÅãµÛ®t²§¡C

ªí6. ¥[¼ö®É¶¡»P³Î°£ª¼¸z¹ï¥h´ß¤j¨§²Ë¤§´áÁB¥¿¯u¥NÁ¯઺¼vÅT(¸ÕÅç2)1,2,3    

¥[¼ö®É¶¡(¤À) Âû°¦«¬ºA
¥¼³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦ ³Î°£ª¼¸zÂû°¦
0 2.719 2.314
20 2.803 2.483
40 2.842 2.350
¥­§¡­È 2.788 2.382
¦@¦P¼Ð·Ç°¾·Ç 0.054

1. 3°¦Âûªº¥­§¡­È¡C

2. Âû°¦«¬ºAªº¥D®ÄÀ³¦³ÅãµÛ®t²§(P¡Õ0.001)¡A¥[¼ö®É¶¡ªº¥D®ÄÀ³»P¥[¼ö®É¶¡¡ÑÂû°¦«¬ºA¨S¦³ÅãµÛ¥æ·P®ÄÀ³(P¡Ö0.1)¡C

3. ¨C§J°®ª«½èªº¥a¥d¯à¶q­È¡C

¹}®ÆÀç¾iÂø»x(p.12¡ã18)¢w³¯²KºÖ¡D¤E¤T¦~²Ä¤Q¤@´Á