¦b¹å¤Æ«á3¦Ü6¶g´Á¶¡
¤½¥À¦×Âû¤§¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä»Ý¨D¶q
ºKn
°µ¸ÕÅç¡A½T©w¹å¤Æ«á22~43¤éÄÖ´Á¶¡¡A¤½¥À¦×Âû(Ross¡ÑRoss)¤§¹}®Æ¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä»Ý¨D¶q¡C¤@ºØ§t¦³¥É¦Ì¡B¦Ð¤ò¯»¤Î¶À¨§¯»¡A§@§¹¾ã³J¥Õ½è·½¤§»²±jÓi°ò»Ä¤§°ò¥»¹}®Æ¡A¨Ñµ¹0.63¢HÁ`Â÷Ói»Ä¡A20¢HCP¤Î3,200 kcal MEn¡þkg¡C·í¥H¥¿½T¹}¾i¤§¥hª¼¸zªº¦¨¤p¤½Âû¸ÕÅç´ú©w®É¡A¦¹°ò¥»¹}®Æ§t¦³0.51¢H¯u¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä¡Cµ¹»P¦³L-Â÷Ói»Ä¹L¶q¤ô·Ç¤§°ò¥»¹}®ÆÂû¡A¨ä¦¨ªø²v¤Î¹}®Æ®Ä²v¡Aµ¥©ó¨º¨Çµ¹»P¥Ò²¸Ói»Ä»²§U¥Ò²¸Ói»Ä¤§¥É¦Ì¢w¶À¨§¯»¥¿¹ï·Ó¹}®ÆÂû(20¢HCP¡F3,200 kcal MEn¡þkg)¡C²K¥[«~¯Å¤ô·Ç¤§¦X¦¨L¢wÂ÷Ói»Ä(0¡A0.1¡A0.2¡A0.3¡A0.4¡A0.5¡A0.6¢H)©ó°ò¥»¹}®Æ¡A²£¥Í¦¨ªø¤ÏÀ³¦±½u¡C¥H¦¨ªø¼Æ¾Ú§@¯}½u¤ÀªRÅã¥Ü¡A¹ï¤½Âû³Ì¤jÅé¼W«¤§¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä»Ý¨D¶q¬°0.85¢H¡A¹ï¥ÀÂû¬°0.78¢H¡C³Ì¾A¹}®Æ®Ä²v¤§»Ý¨D¶q¸û°ª¡G¹ï¤½Âû¬°0.89¢H¡A¹ï¥ÀÂû¬°0.85¢H¡C¯Ý¦Ù(pectoralis majar)¹ïÂ÷Ói»Ä²K¥[²£¥Í¤G¶µªº¼W¥[¤ÏÀ³¡A¥B¦¹¤ÏÀ³Åã¥Ü¡A¹ï³Ì¤j¯Ý¦Ù²£²v¤§Â÷Ói»Ä»Ý¨D¶q¡A¨S¦³¤j¤£¦P©ó¦Û¹}®Æ®Ä²v¼Æ¾Ú©Ò¹wª¾ªº¡C¦Û²Ä¤@¦¸¦Ü²Ä¤G¦¸Â÷Ói»Ä¼W¶q¡A¸¡³¡¯×ªÕ¼W¥[¡A¦ý·íÂ÷Ói¤ô·Ç§ó¥[¼W¥[®É¡A´N°§C¡C
¤@¡B«e¨¥
¹Á¸ÕÀ³¥Î²z·Q¤§³J¥Õ½èÆ[©À¡A°t»s¦×Âû¹}®Æ¡A¦ôp¥i®ø¤Æ¤§¥¿½T»Ý¨D¶q«Ü«n(Baker¤ÎHan¡A1994)¡C¦b¦×Âû¹}®Æ¡AÂ÷Ói»Ä±`¬O¤@ºØ¨îÓi°ò»Ä¡C¦]¦¹¡A¦b²z·Q³J¥Õ½è½d¦¡¡A¥Î§@¥Î¶q¤Æ¨ä¥L¥²»ÝÓi°ò»Ä¤§°Ñ¦ÒÓi°ò»Ä¡C´¿¼sªx¬ã¨s¡A¦ôp¦×Âû¤§Â÷Ói»Ä»Ý¨D¶q(Boomgaardt¤ÎBaker¡A1973¡FThomas¡A1978¡FHan¤ÎBaker¡A1991¡F1993¡FBilzili¡A1992¡FHolsheimer¤ÎReerkamp¡A1992)¡C¦ý¦b3~6¶g¦¨ªø´Á¶¡¡A¤´«Ü¨î¦×Âû¤§¥i®ø¤Æ(©Î¥Íª«¦³®Ä©Ê)Â÷Ói»Ä»Ý¨D¶q¤§¦n°T®§¡C¦AªÌ¡A²{¤µ½T¹êÃҹꤽ¦×Âû¤§¹}®ÆÓi°ò»Ä»Ý¨D¶q¡A¸û°ª©ó¥À¦×Âû(Thomas¡A1986¡F1987¡FHan¤ÎBaker¡A1993)¡C²{¤µNRC(1994)±ÀÂË¡A3~6¶gÄÖ¤§¤½¡B¥À¦×Âû¡A¨äÁ`Â÷Ói»Ä»Ý¨D¶q¬°1.00¢H¡C¥»³ø§i¬ã¨s¤§¥Øªº¡A¬°¬ã¨s©Ê§O¹ï»²§UÂ÷Ói»Ä¤§¤ÏÀ³¡A¤Î½T©w¦b¹å¤Æ«á22~43¤é¤§´Á¶¡¡A¤½¥À¦×Âû¤§¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä»Ý¨D¶q¡C
¤G¡Bì®Æ¤Î¤èªk
1. °ò¥»¹}®Æ
¹ï¹å¤Æ3~6¶g¤§¦×Âû¡A½Õ»s¤@°£Â÷Ói»Ä¥~¡A¨ä¥L©Ò¦³Àç¾i¾A¦X©Î¶W¹LNRC(1994)©Ò±ÀÂˤ§§¹¾ã³J¥Õ½è°ò¥»¹}®Æ¡C¹}®Æ½Õ»s«e¡A§Q¥Î24¤p®É»Ä¤ô¸Ñ¡A¤ÀªR¹}®Æ¤¤§t³J¥Õ½è²Õ¦¨ª«(¥É¦Ì¡B¦Ð¤ò¤Î¶À¨§¯»)¤§²Ê³J¥Õ½è(AOA¡A1980)¡A±µµÛÂÇÂ÷¤l¥æ´«¼hªR¡A¤ÀªRÓi°ò»Ä(Spackman¡A1958)¡C§Q¥Î¦P¤@§å¤§²Õ¦¨ª«¡A²V¦X©Ò¦³¸ÕÅ礧¹}®Æ¡C¨C¤@¦¨ªø¸ÕÅ礧°ò¥»¹}®Æ¡A§t¦³3,200 kcal MEn¡þkg¡A20¢HCP¤Î0.63¢HÁ`Â÷Ói»Ä¡C¥H¹}®Æ¯ÅL-Â÷Ói»ÄÆQ»ÄÆQ(79¢H)¡A¨Ñµ¹Â÷Ói»Ä²K¥[ª«©ó°ò¥»¹}®Æ¡A¨Ã°²³]©Ò²K¥[¤§µ²´¹Â÷Ói»Ä¬°100¢H¥Íª«¦³®Ä©Ê(Izquierdo¡A1988)¡C
2. Â÷Ói»Ä®ø¤Æ²v¸ÕÅç(¸ÕÅç1)
§Q¥Î¦¨¼ô¡A¥hª¼¸z¤§³æ«a¥Õ¨Ó¦ë¤p¤½Âû¡A´ú©w°ò¥»¹}®Æ¤¤¤§Â÷Ói»Ä¯u®ø¤Æ²v(ªí1)(Han ¤Î Parsons¡A1990)¡C³{¾÷¿ï¨ú5°¦¤p¤½Âû¡Aµ¹»P35§J¤§úPÅn´¡¤J°ò¥»¹}®Æ¡A¥t5°¦¤p¤½Âû¡A¥Î§@¹}®Æ¤§¹ï·Ó¡A¦ôp¤º¥Í±Æªn¤§Ói°ò»Ä¡C¸ÕÅçÂû¨î©óÓ§O¦¬¶°ÂûÅ¢¡A¦b48¤p®É¦¬¶°´Á¶¡¡A¦¬¶°±Æªnª«©ó¶ì½¦¸Õ½L¡C¨C¤@¤p¤½Âû¤§±Æªnª«¡A°®Àê§Ná¡A¯¯¶q¡A¸g60¥Ø¿zºô¿i¸H¡AµM«á¦p«ez¡A¤ÀªRÂ÷Ói»Ä¡C¥HHan¤ó©Òz¡Apºâ°ò¥»¹}®Æ¤§¯u¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä(1993)¡C
3. ¦¨ªø¸ÕÅç(¸ÕÅç2~4)
¦b¸ÕÅç2¡A«Y§Q¥Î·sº~¥¬®L¡Ñ¥iÛ¤ñ¨ÈÂø¥æ¤½Âû¡A¦b¸ÕÅç3¡A«Y§Q¥ÎRoss¡ÑRoss¤½Âû¡A¸ÕÅç4«Y§Q¥ÎRoss¡ÑRoss¥ÀÂû¡C¦Û¹å¤Æ¦Ü¹å¤Æ«á22¤é¡A¨Ñ¸ÕÂûµ¹»P±j¤Æ¥Ò²¸Ói»Ä¤§¼Ð·Ç23¢HCP¤§¥É¦Ì¶À¨§¯»¹}®Æ(3,200 kcal MEn¡þkg)¡C¦b²Ä22¤é¡A¥h°£¹}®Æ¸g4¤p®É¡AµM«áÓ§O¯¯«¡B±a¦ÐÀô¡B¤À°t¹}®Æ¤Î¨|ÂúÄæ¡A¨Ï¦b¨C¤@¸ÕÅ示¤§¨C¤@Äæ¡A±N¦³«Ü±µªñ¤§¤@¼Ë¥§¡ªìÅ髤Ϋ¶q¬É¡C¨Ñ¸ÕÂûºû«ù©ó·Å«×±±¨î«Ø¿vª«¤º¤§¦³¥iª@ÅKµ·ºô¦aªO¤§¨|¦¨¨|Âú¾¹¡C¨C¤@¹}®Æ³B²z¥]¬A¨CÄæ5°¦¤§¥|Äæ¡C¥ô¨Ñ¹}®Æ¤Î¶¼¤ô¡A¨Ãºû«ù24¤p®É¤@©w¤§¥ú·Ó¡C¦b¹å¤Æ«á22~43¤é´Á¶¡¡A¹ê¬I©Ò¦³¸ÕÅç¡C¨C¶g´ú©w¤@©wÅ髤ι}®Æ®ø¯Ó¡C
¦b¸ÕÅç2¨Ï¥ÎÂ÷¥æ¤½Âû(·sº~¥¬®L¡Ñ¥iÛ¤ñ¨È)¡C¥»¸ÕÅ礧¥Øªº¡A¬O¤ñ¸ûµ¹»P¦³¤ÎµL¹L¶q¤ô·Ç(0.6¢H)¤§L-Â÷Ói»Ä±j¤Æ¤§¸ÕÅç¹}®Æ(ªí1)¡A»Pµ¹»P»²§UDL-¥Ò²¸Ói»Ä¤§¤H¶Ç²Î¥É¦Ì¢w¶À¨§¯»¹}®ÆÂû(20¢HCP¡A3,200 kcal MEn¡þkg)¡A¨ä¦¨ªø©Ê¯à¤Î¹}®Æ®Ä²v¡C
¸ÕÅç3´ú©wRoss¡ÑRoss¤½¦×Âû¤§Â÷Ói»Ä»Ý¨D¶q¡C¥HL-Â÷Ói»ÄÆQ»ÄÆQ»²§U°ò¥»¹}®Æ(ªí1)¡A¨Ñµ¹0¡A0.1¡A0.2¡A0.3¡A0.4©Î0.6¢H²K¥[¤§L-Â÷Ói»Ä¡C¥§¡ªìÅ髬°770§J¡C¸ÕÅçµ²§ô¡AÓ§O¯¯¨Ñ¸ÕÂû«¡C³Ì±µªñÄ椧¥§¡Å髪º¨C¤@Ä椺¡A¥HCO2®_±þ3°¦¡C¤Á°£¯Ý¦×(µL¥Ö¤§pectoralis majar)¡A¨Ã¯¯«¡F¥ç¥h°£¥]¬A³ò¶¬âÅn¤§¯×ªÕªº¸¡³¡¯×ªÕ¡A¨Ã¯¯«¡C
°£¥»¸ÕÅ礧¥Øªº¬O¡A½T¹êRoss¡ÑRoss¥ÀÂû¤§Â÷Ói»Ä»Ý¨D¶q¤§¥~¡A¸ÕÅç4¤§³]pÃþ¦ü¸ÕÅç3¡C¦b¸ÕÅçµ²§ô(²Ä43¤é)¡A¦p¸ÕÅç3©Òz¡A¨C¤@Äæ¿ï¨ú3°¦¡CÂÇ©ñ¦å®_±þ¨Ñ¸ÕÂû¡AµM«á¦Û°Ó·~©Ê¥[¤u¼t¡AÓ§O¥[¤u¡C¥h°£¯Ý¦×(µL¥Ö½§¤§pectoralis majar)¤Î¸¡³¡¯×ªÕ¹Ô¡A¨Ã¯¯«¡C
ªí1. ¯Ê¥FÂ÷Ói»Ä°ò¥»¹}®Æ¤§²Õ¦¨(1)
²Õ¦¨¥÷ | ¢H |
¥É¦Ì¾ý¯» | ¦Ü100.00 |
¥É¦Ì(7.48¢HCP) | 72.31 |
¥h¥Ö¶À¨§¯»(48.78¢HCP) | 4.00 |
¦Ð¤ò¯»(85.06¢HCP) | 14.86 |
¥É¦Ìªo | 3.36 |
ÁC»Ä¤G¶t | 2.00 |
¥Û¦Ç¥Û | 1.00 |
¹ÆQ(¸K¤Æ) | 0.40 |
·L¶qÄqª«½è²V¦Xª«(2) | 0.15 |
ºû¥Í¯À²V¦Xª«(3) | 0.20 |
´â¤ÆÁxÆP(60¢H) | 0.10 |
Flavomycin¹w²Vª«(4) | 0.15 |
D1-¥Ò²¸Ói»Ä | 0.30 |
1-ºëÓi»Ä | 0.20 |
1-¦âÓi»Ä | 0.10 |
(1)§t¦³20¢HCP¡A3,200 kcal MEn¡þkg¡A¤Î0.63¢HÂ÷Ói»Ä
(2)¨Ckg¹}®Æ¨Ñµ¹¡G¿ø75mg¡FÅK75mg¡F¾N75mg¡F»É5mg¡F¸K0.35mg¡FÖ´0.1mg
(3)¨Ckg¹}®Æ¨Ñµ¹¡Gretinyl acetate 4,400 IU ; choecalciferol 1,000 IU¡FD1-2-tocopheryl acetate 11 IU¡FµÒÆP»Ä22mg¡FD-ªx»Ä10mg¡Friboflavin 4.4mg¡FMenadione«¨È²¸»Ä¶u²V¦Xª«2.33mg¡Fºû¥Í¯ÀB12 0.1mg
(4)¨Ñµ¹2.2mg¡þkg¤§flavomycin
4. ²Îp¤ÀªR
¥HANOVA¤èªk³B²z¦¨ªø¸ÕÅ礧¼Æ¾Ú¡A°jÂk§Q¥ÎSAS³nÅ餧¤@¯ëª½½u¼Ò¦¡(GLM)¤èªk¤§§¹¥þ³{¾÷³]p(Steel¤ÎTorrie¡A1980)¡C¦]¦b¤£¦P®É¶¡§@¸ÕÅç3¤Î4(§Y©Ê§O¡ÑÂ÷Ói»Ä)¡A©Ò¥HÓ§O¸ÕÅç³B²z¡A¤£¥H²Õ¦X¦]¯À³]p³B²z¡C¦b¸ÕÅç2¡A§Q¥Î³Ì¤pÅãµÛ®t²§¡AÂù¤è±½Æ¦¡¤ñ¸û¤èªk(Carmer¤ÎWalker¡A1985)¡A¤À¶}¥§¡¼Æ¡CÂǵê½u¤èªk½×¡A¦ôpÅé¼W«¤Î¹}®Æ®Ä²v¤§¥i®ø¤Æ¤§Â÷Ói»Ä»Ý¨D¶q¡A¦ý¥ç°t¦X¤@º¥ªñ¤§¼Ò¦¡(Robbins¡A1979)¡C
¤T¡Bµ²ªG¤Î°Q½×
¥H¥h°£ª¼¸z¤§¦¨¤p¤½Âû½T©w¡A¥É¦Ì¢w¦Ð¤ò¯»¢w¶À¨§¯»¹}®Æ¤¤¤§Â÷Ói»Ä¯u®ø¤Æ²v¡A¬°81.2¢H(ªí2)¡C¦]¦¹¡A°ò¥»¹}®Æ¨Ñµ¹0.51¢H¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä(0.63¢H¡Ñ81.2¢H)¡C
ªí2. °ò¥»¹}®Æ¤¤¤§¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä¤§½T©w(1)
³B²z | Â÷Ói»ÄÄá¨úmg | Â÷Ói»Ä±Æªnmg | Â÷Ói»Ä¯u®ø¤Æ²v¢H |
¥h¹}®Æ | 0 | 25.6 | ¢w |
µ¹»P | 220.5 | 67.0 | 81.2 |
SEM | ¢w | 2.9 | 1.9 |
(1)¼Æ¾Ú¬°5°¦¥hª¼¸z¦¨¤p¤½Âû¤§¥§¡¼Æ
µ¹»PµL»²§U¤§°ò¥»¹}®Æ¦×Âû¡A¨ä¦H¦¨ªø²v¤Î¹}®Æ®Ä²vÅã¥ÜÄY«¯Ê¥FÂ÷Ói»Ä(ªí3)¡C¥H¹L¶q¤§Â÷Ói»Ä¤ô·Ç(0.6¢H)±j¤Æ¤§°ò¥»¹}®Æ¡A¤£¶È¾ÉP¤j§ïµ½Åé¼W«¤Î¹}®Æ®Ä²v¡A¦ý¥ç²£¥Í¬Û¦P©óµ¹»P¶Ç²Î¤§¥É¦Ì¢w¶À¨§¯»¹}®ÆÂû¤§¦¨ªø©Ê¯à¡C¥»¸ÕÅ礧¼Æ¾ÚÃÒ¹ê¡A°ò¥»¹}®Æ¤§Â÷Ói»Ä§t¶q¡A°÷§C²£¥Í¦³¥Î¤§Â÷Ói»Ä¤ÏÀ³¦±½u¡C
ªí3¡B¸ÕÅç2¡A¯Ê¥FÂ÷Ói»Ä°ò¥»¹}®Æ¤§µû»ù(1)
¹}®Æ(2) | ¼W«(g) | ¼W«¡þ¹}®Æ(g¡þkg) |
1. ¥É¦Ì¶À¨§¯»¹ï·Ó | 781a | 485a |
2. °ò¥»¹}®Æ | 324b | 298b |
3. °ò¥»¹}®Æ¡Ï0.6¢H | 772a | 498a |
Â÷Ói»Ä¶°p¤§SEM | 22 | 10 |
(a.b)¡GÄ椺¦³¤£¦P¤å¦r¤§¥§¡¼Æ¡A¦³ÅãµÛ®t(p¡Õ0.05)
(1)¡G¼Æ¾Ú¬°¹å¤Æ«á22~43¤é¡A5°¦¤½Âû(·sº~¥¬®L¡Ñ¥iÛ¤ñ¨È)¤§5¸s¥§¡¼Æ¡F¥§¡ªì«¬°376g
(2)©Ò¦³¹}®Æ½Õ»s§t¦³20¢HCP¤Î3,200 kcal MEn¡þkg
(3)§t¦³59.3¢H¥É¦Ì¡A31.9¢H¥h¥Ö¶À¨§¯»¡A4.9¢H¶À¨§ªo¡A0.12¢HD1-¥Ò²¸Ói»Ä¤Î»Ýn¤§ºû¥Í¯À¡BÄqª«½è¤Î§Ü¥Í¯À(flavomycin)±j¤Æ(¦pªí1)
¤½¦×Âû¤§¼W«¡B¹}®ÆÄá¨ú¤Î¼W«¡þ¹}®Æ¤ñ(¸ÕÅç3)¡A·|¤G¦¸¤ÏÀ³(p¡Õ0.05)¼W¶q¤§¹}®ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä²K¥[(ªí4)¡Cª½¦Ü0.91¢H¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä¡A¼W«¤Î¼W«¡þ¹}®Æ¤ñ¡Aª½½u¼W«(p¡Õ0.05)¡A¦ý¦b0.81¢H©Î¥H¤U¡A¹}®ÆÄá¨ú¦ü¥G¹F¦y®p¡C¦b¸û¦~»´Âû¥ç´¿µo²{¡A¹ï³Ì¤j¹}®ÆÄá¨ú»Ýn¤§Â÷Ói»Ä¤ô·Ç¡A¸û§C©ó¹ï³Ì¤j¼W«©Î¹}®Æ®Ä²v©Ònªº¤ô·Ç(Han¤ÎBaker¡A1991¡F1993)¡C
°t¦X¤§¤¤Â_½uÅã¥Ü(¹Ï1)Åã¥Ü¡A¹ï¤½Âû¼W«¤Î¹}®Æ®Ä²v¡AÂ_ÂI¦U§O¦b0.85¤Î0.89¢H¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä¡Cª½¦Ü0.91¢H¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä¡A¯Ý«ª½½u¼W¥[(p¡Õ0.05)¡AµM«á¹FÅãµÛ¤§¦y®p¡AÁöµM³Ì°ª¤§¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä¤ô·Ç(1.11¢H)·|¾ÉP³Ì¤j¯Ý«¤Î²£¶q(ªí4)¡C
ªí4. µ¹»P«~¯Å¤ô·Ç¤§¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä¤½¦×Âû¤§¦¨ªø©Ê¯à¤Î±OÅé¸ê®Æ¡A¸ÕÅç3(1)
¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä(¢H) | 43¤éÄÖÅé«(2)(g) | ¼W«(2)(g¡þd) | ¹}®ÆÄá¨ú(2)(g¡þd) | ¼W«¡þ¹}®Æ(2)(g¡þkg) | ¯Ý¦× | ¸¡³¡¯×ªÕ²£²v | |
«¶q(2)(g) | ²£¶q(2)(¢H) | ||||||
0.51 | 1,394 | 29.7 | 90.6 | 327 | 133.5 | 9.5 | 1.91 |
0.61 | 1,630 | 41.0 | 110.6 | 370 | 166.8 | 10.5 | 2.25 |
0.71 | 1,821 | 50.1 | 114.7 | 436 | 195.3 | 10.9 | 2.29 |
0.81 | 1,937 | 55.6 | 122.8 | 454 | 213.1 | 10.8 | 2.26 |
0.91 | 2,035 | 60.2 | 122.3 | 493 | 225.7 | 10.9 | 1.95 |
1.01 | 2,056 | 61.2 | 123.1 | 498 | 225.7 | 10.9 | 1.96 |
1.11 | 2,044 | 60.7 | 119.8 | 507 | 250.0 | 12.0 | 1.70 |
SEM | 29 | 1.4 | 3.2 | 9 | 12.9 | 0.6 | 0.26 |
(1)©Ê¯à¼Æ¾Ú¬°¨C¸s5°¦Ross¡ÑRoss¤½¦×Âû¹å¤Æ«á22~43¤é¤§¥|¸s¥§¡¼Æ¡F¥§¡ªì«¬°770g¡C±OÅé¼Æ¾Ú¬°¨CÄæ¨ä³Ì²×Å髳̱µªñ¨C¸s¥§¡¤§3°¦ªº¥§¡¼Æ¡C¥H³Ì²×Å髤§¢Hªí¥Ü¯Ý¦Ù²£¶q¤Î¸¡³¡¯×ªÕ²£¶q
(2)¤G¦¸¤ÏÀ³(p¡Õ0.05)
(3)¸¡³¡¯×ªÕ¥]¬A¬âÅn
Hickling(1990)¤ÎBigili(1992)´¿ªí¥Ü¡A¹ï³Ì¤j¯Ý¦×²£¶q¤§Ói°ò»Ä»Ý¨D¶q¡A¥i¯à¸û¤j©ó¹ï³Ì¤j¦¨ªø²v¤§»Ý¨D¶q¡C¦ýSummers¤ó³ø§i(1988)¡A¨Ï¥Î¸û°ª¤ô·Ç¤§»²§UÂ÷Ói»Ä¡B¥Ò²¸Ói»Ä¡A¨S¦³§ïµ½¥i¹¦×¤§²£¶q¡CÁöµM¦b³Ì°ª¤ô·Ç¤§¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä(§Y1.11¢H)¡A¯Ý«¦³¼W¥[ÁͦV¡A¦ý§C©ó³Ì°ªÂ÷Ói»Ä¤ô·Ç¤§¨â¤ô·Ç¡A¥ß§Y¾ÉP¯Ý«»P²£¶q¨S¦³®t²§¡C¦]¦¹§Ṳ́§µ²ªG¡A³Ì¤j¯Ý¦×²£¶q¤Î³Ì¤j¹}®Æ®Ä²v¡A»Ýn¤@¸û°ª¹}®ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä¤ô·Ç¤§±ÀÂË¡C
°t¦X¤§¤¤Â_½u(¹Ï1)Åã¥Ü¡A¦b3~6¶g¤§¦¨ªø´Á¶¡¡A¤½Âû¤ñ¥ÀÂû¤§»Ý¨D¶q¸û°ª¡C¨Ï¥Î¸û¦~»´Âû¡AÃÒ¾ÚÅã¥Ü¤½¦×Âû¤ñ¥À¦×Âû»Ý¨D¸û°ª¤§Â÷Ói»Ä¤ô·Ç(Han¤ÎBaker¡A1993)¡A³Ì¤j¤§¹}®Æ®Ä²v¤ñ³Ì¤j¤§¼W«¡A¥ç»Ýn¸û°ª¤§Â÷Ói»Ä¤ô·Ç(Han¤ÎBaker¡A1991¡F1993)¡C¦Û°¨¨½Äõ(Huncher¤ÎThomas¡A1976¡FKessler¤ÎThomas¡A1976)¤§¬ã¨s´¿Åã¥Ü¡A¦Û¹å¤Æ«á4~7¶g¡A¤½Âû¹ïºëÓi»Ä¤Î¥ÕÓi»Ä¤§»Ý¨D¶q¡A¸û¤j©ó¥ÀÂû¡C¤½¦×Âû»Ýn¤ñ¥ÀÂû¸û°ª¤ô·Ç¤§Ói°ò»Ä¡A¦ü¥G¦XÅÞ¿è¡A¦]¤½Âû¦b¹å¤Æ«á0~3¶g¡A¤Î3~6¶g¡A¨ä¼W«¤¤§t¸û¦h³J¥Õ½è¤Î¸û¤Ö¯×ªÕ(Edwards¡A1973¡FKubena¡A1974¡FHurwitz¡A1980¡FHan¤ÎBaker¡A1991)¡C
¦b°t»s¦Ü20¢HCP¤§¨å«¬ªº¥É¦Ì¤Î¶À¨§¯»¹}®Æ¤¤¡A¥É¦Ì±N¨Ñµ¹¬ù25¢H¤§CP¡A¶À¨§¯»±N¨Ñµ¹¨ä¾l¤§75¢H¡A®Ú¾ÚParsons(1991)©Ò½s¦C¤§¯u®ø¤Æ²v¸ê®Æ¡Apºâ³oºØ¹}®Æ¤§Â÷Ói»Ä®ø¤Æ²v¡A¬ù¬°88¢H¡CÂಾ¦Û¦¹¦a¬ã¨s¤§¦ôp³Ì¾A¤§¹}®Æ®Ä²v¤§»Ý¨D¶q¡A¦Ü¹ê¥Î¤§¥É¦Ì¤Î¶À¨§¯»¹}®Æ±¡§Î¡A¹ï¤½Âû»Ýn1.01¢H¤§Á`¹}®ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä§t¶q¡A¹ï¥ÀÂû»Ýn0.97¢H¡C¹ï²V¦X©Ê§O¹}¾i¡A¥§¡»Ý¨D¶q¬°0.99¢HÂ÷Ói»Ä¡A³o«ÜÃþ¥HNRC(1994)©Ò±ÀÂˤ§1.00¢H¡C
»{¬°¹ï¼W«¤Î¹}®Æ®Ä²v¤§¦¹¦a¸ê®Æ¡A¾A¦X°t¦X¦±½u¡C¾A¦X¤§¤¤Â_½u¡A»¤¥X¤@¥Øªº°j§éÂI¡A³o¥i¥Î©ó½T©w½Ñ¦p©Ê§O¤§¤£¦P¦]¯À¡A·|¦p¦ó¼vÅT¹wª¾¤§»Ý¨D¶q¡C¦ýÅãµMªº¡A¤@¾A¦X»Ý¨D¶q¤§¿ï¾Ü¡A¬°¤@¸gÀÙ°ÝÃD¡A¥É¦Ì¡B¶À¨§¯»¡Bµ²´¹Â÷Ói»Ä¤ÎÂû¤§Å鳡¥÷(¦p¯Ý³¡)¡A¬°¥²¶·¦Ò¼{¤§©Ò¦³¦]¯À¡C¹Ï2ªí¥Ü¡A¥H¹ï¤½Âû¤Î¥ÀÂû¤§¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä¿@«×¬°¨ç¼Æ¡A¹}®Æ®Ä²v¤§³Ì¾Aº¥ªñ¦±½u¡C§Q¥Î³o¨Ç¦±½u¤Î±Ôz¤§¤èµ{¦¡¡A¥LÌ¥i¥Î§@±N¹F³Ì¤j¸gÀÙ§Q¼í¡A¿ï¾Ü¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä¤ô·Ç¤§°ò¦¡C
ªí5. µ¹»P«~¯Å¤ô·Ç¤§¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä¤§¥À¦×Âû¤§¦¨ªø©Ê¯à¤Î±OÅé¼Æ¾Ú¡A¸ÕÅç4(1)
¥i®ø¤ÆÂ÷Ói»Ä(¢H) | 43¤éÄÖÅé«(2)(g) | ¼W«(2)(g¡þd) | ¹}®ÆÄá¨ú(2)(g¡þd) | ¼W«¡þ¹}®Æ(2)(g¡þkg) | ¯Ý¦× | ¸¡³¡¯×ªÕ²£²v(2)(3) | |
«¶q(2)(g) | ²£¶q(2)(¢H) | ||||||
0.51 | 1,222 | 24.8 | 76.0 | 325 | 120.9 | 10.0 | 1.6 |
0.61 | 1,456 | 35.9 | 91.8 | 391 | 150.9 | 10.3 | 1.7 |
0.71 | 1,677 | 46.4 | 106.6 | 435 | 185.7 | 11.1 | 1.7 |
0.81 | 1,789 | 51.3 | 108.8 | 472 | 208.5 | 11.9 | 1.6 |
0.91 | 1,823 | 53.4 | 109.8 | 486 | 216.2 | 11.9 | 1.5 |
1.01 | 1,813 | 52.9 | 107.4 | 492 | 219.6 | 12.1 | 1.3 |
1.11 | 1,834 | 53.9 | 108.3 | 498 | 222.4 | 12.2 | 1.4 |
SEM | 20 | 1.0 | 1.7 | 4 | 5.1 | 0.2 | 0.1 |
(1)©Ê¯à¼Æ¾Ú¬°¨C¸s5°¦Ross¡ÑRoss¤½¦×Âû¹å¤Æ«á22~43¤é¤§¥|¸s¥§¡¼Æ¡F¥§¡ªì«¬°702g¡C±OÅé¼Æ¾Ú¬°¨CÄ椧³Ì²×Å髳̱µªñ¨C¸s¥§¡¤§3°¦ªº¥§¡¼Æ¡C¥H³Ì²×Å髤§¢Hªí¥Ü¯Ý¦Ù²£¶q¤Î¸¡³¡¯×ªÕ²£²v
(2)¤G¦¸¤ÏÀ³(p¡Õ0.05)
(3)¸¡³¡¯×ªÕ¥]¬A¬âÅn
¹}®ÆÀç¾iÂø»x(p.61¡ã68)¢w³¯«p°ò¡D¤E¤¦~²Ä¤Q¤@´Á
Copyright © 1998 Z¸s®n¯bªªºô.
¥»ºô¯¸¹Ï¤å«YÄÝZ¸s®n¦³¤½¥q¡A¤º¤å¤§ª©Åv¬°¸ÓÂø»xªÀ©Ò
¦³¡A«D¸g¥»¤½¥q¤Î¸ÓÂø»xªÀ¥¿¦¡®Ñ±¦P·N¡A¤£±o±N¥þ³¡©Î³¡¤À¤º®e¡A
Âà¸ü©ó¥ô¦ó§Î¦¡´CÅé
¡° ³Ì¨Î¸ÑªR«× 800x600
Copyright © 1998
MiobufferCo., Ltd. All rights reserved.
Unauthorized copying and reproduction is prohibited. All trademarks property of their
respective holders.